Parental Alienation

Alienation In High-Conflict Divorce

Goldberg Jones Child Custody, Divorce, Featured Posts 2 Comments

It’s not uncommon for people to pick sides in high-conflict divorce. The process often turns people against one another, especially in contentious cases where emotions run hot. Never easy, it’s exceedingly painful when it involves children in a phenomenon called parental alienation.

It’s much more complex than this, but during divorce, parental alienation serves as a blanket term for one parent turning a child against the other. It encompasses a wide range. This may be one parent negatively influencing a child’s view of the other parent or even go as far as fabricated abuse allegations. Children can be aloof and withdrawn or outright hostile. This is often devastating to the targeted parent. Many also consider it emotional child abuse.

How Parental Alienation Impacts Divorce And Custody

In divorce and custody cases, the court’s primary concern is the best interests of the child. Parental alienation can figure into a case if the targeted parent shows that the alienating parent is willfully and intentionally interfering with the parent-child relationship. The court doesn’t look favorably on this. Though it isn’t always an easy thing to prove, so it’s important to prepare.

Tactics for creating this distance and conflict vary. They include things like saying negative things about the other parent. They often paint the other as monstrous while setting themselves up as wonderful. It can begin with undermining trust in the other parent or undercutting their authority. Maybe the target parent’s rules don’t apply or the kids are allowed to do whatever they want to curry favor.  

If your ex has a history of interfering with your relationship, take steps to document this. Also, compile evidence of a healthy relationship with your child. If you can support claims that you’ve had a positive relationship in the past, it may help prove manipulation. Showing a progression about how your relationship went from good to bad often helps cases. If you have the resources and opportunity, consider having an expert in parental alienation, a therapist or psychologist, testify on your behalf.

Criteria For Parental Alienation

There’s a difference between a child being estranged from a parent and parental alienation. Alienation is when a child rejects a parent based on unjustified reasons; when they refuse to see a loving parent.

A mental health professional must diagnose parental alienation, but it’s important to know what to look for in a child. The book Parental Alienation: Handbook for Mental Health and Legal Professionals generally serves as one of the standard texts on the subject.

Based solely on the child’s behavior, not the parents, parental alienation breaks down the symptoms into a number of criteria:

  • Campaign of denigration against the target parent..” Here, the child lists complaints against the target parent. This includes trivial, irrational, and even false claims. They may even deny ever having positive experiences with the parent in question.
  • Frivolous rationalizations for the child’s criticism of the target parent..” Based on the circumstances, the hostility, disgust, and contempt are “unjustified and disproportionate.” The children often claim to be scared, but “easily and without typical fear reactions.” Essentially, they say one thing but act contrary.

Parental alienation occurs when a child checks off both of these boxes and also displays two of the following behaviors:

  • Lack of ambivalence.” There’s no middle ground. The child idealizes one parent while degrading and demonizing the other.
  • Independent-thinker phenomenon..” This occurs when the child steadfastly denies being influenced or manipulated. They insist the conclusion is their own alone.
  • Reflexive support of the alienating parent against the target parent..” This is when the child sides against the target parent without hesitation or question. Whatever the issue, that parent is in the wrong.
  • Absence of guilt over exploitation and mistreatment of target parent.” The child shows no remorse or guilt for negative behavior towards the target parent or concern for the effect.
  • Borrowed scenarios.” This is when a child tells a story identical to the alienating parent’s. Occasionally they may borrow from an older sibling. In these cases, the children are often unable to provide any additional detail to elaborate on or substantiate their claims.
  • Spread the child’s animosity toward the target parent’s extended family.It’s not uncommon for the child to direct his or her expressions of hatred and disdain to the target parent’s extended family. This includes grandparents and even family pets.

With all of these variables in play, it’s easy to see why it’s up to professionals to diagnose parental alienation. These criteria are sound very abstract, but in a practical sense, this behavior dehumanizes one parent. It creates a scenario where one parent is good and the other parent is bad. This can be a nightmare for a parent, to see a beloved child turned against them.

Parental alienation is often devastating for parents. If you have questions about divorce or child custody, feel free to contact Goldberg Jones at our San Diego office.

Comments 2

  1. Hello,
    I am a mother who feels I am being alienated from my children. Could you help me please?
    I am currently involved in a custody battle and evaluation. I have retained lawyer Mr. Thomas Huguenor. I’m currently looking for advice re: local therapists in La Jolla that specifically deal with reunification therapy. My ex has significantly harmed my relationships with my children and has undermined trust between myself and them. Many of the signs of parental alienation outlined here are occurring and have extended to my side of the family.

    1. Post
      Author

      Thanks for reaching out, Natasha. That’s a tough situation. I passed your contact information along to our managing attorney, Zephyr Hill. He will reach out to you shortly with more information. Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *